Requirements for a Drug-like Sound
[There was another fire about a mile south of us again today. The wind, blowing East, caused evacuations and, I imagine, difficulty breathing as it swept toward Boulder this time and not us. It appears to be out as I write this]
In order to make progress here, I will go out on a limb and just start listing things *I* think are present when I have experienced large does of Drug-like sound in the past:
* Decent to excellent Micro-dynamics
* Very High resolution
* Good, often vivid harmonics
* Good continuousness, sometimes even good PRaT
SUSCEPTIBILITY
Personally [and all of this is personal, but hopefully there will be consensus as you all reflect upon your experiences], I am often ‘lulled’ by the music [sometimes assisted by being tired from overwork on my part] into a dream-like state before ‘waking up’ and experiencing some really cool mind-blowing experiences.
So let us assume that there is an extreme comfort with the sound [and the situation] required as a prerequisite for us to even appreciate a drug-like sound.
It is this lulling into a susceptible, dream-like state that I think requires a sound that the listener is very comfortable with, a sound that matches their preferences quite well. I think tiredness can help us ignore some harshness and sound that is NOT exactly to our tastes [but being this tired is not all that much fun, let me tell you :-)].
I think, also, that no matter what your preferences, a decent, perhaps vivid harmonic content is of value to assist the lulling… it’s guarantee of approachable sweetness is comforting.
INGREDIENTS
For me, it seems to be the swirling change of the mathematical relationships between various melodies [which appear to evoke corresponding patterns in the thinking side of the brain. We talked about this several years ago] which kind of occupy and lead my thinking brain places …COMBINED with extreme harmonic color and/or purity [which often sounds extra-vivid during the experience, perhaps because the thinking (distracting) part of the brain is occupied elsewhere] that kind of satiates the emotional ‘heart’ part of the brain.
So…. 🙂 …. *if* we use this as a template for what is required/ happens for / during drug-like music experiences, then we need:
* Decent to excellent Micro-dynamics [and separation, to be able to hear and differentiate the melodies and their relationships to each other]
* Very High resolution [increases the number of melodies – there are beautiful, evocative relationships between the transitions between various harmonics in every tiny note. You can hear this on very big notes like, say, Roy Buchanan “The Messiah will come again”]
* Good, often vivid harmonics [To lull us into a susceptible state and to please and entertain our emotional side during the drug like music experience. In some sense this is the ‘engine’ that keeps us from burning out on too much detail and complexity in the micro-dynamics and high resolution. Note that this does NOT necessarily require tubes, that very good solid-state has a natural purity that tubes must work hard to achieve (but they CAN achieve it!)]
* Good continuousness, sometimes even good PRaT [the melodies are sequences of notes in time, if there are no flowing marching sequences – then there is no melody and one just has a hodgepodge of distinct notes appearing all over the place in the soundstage]
Hi!
Interesting description of the drug induced state. I have definitely experienced something like this, sometimes also when being very tired. You somehow magically move closer to the music, but at the same time it is spread out in front of you in great detail.
As you mentioned earlier bass does not seem to be an essential ingredient. I have been quite happy with a pair of decent monitor speakers, achieving this experience. Probably good accuracy in a limited bandwidth helps more than limited accuracy paired with wide bandwidth.
Good observation re “good accuracy in a lmited bandwith”. Something needs to connect,really CONNECT, with the real thing to transport you into that alternate, but real, place. Something that takes your attention away from what is wrong and to focus on what is right.
Hi Guys,
I REALLY like the “Something that takes your attention away from what is wrong and to focus on what is right.” perspective, Jim.
I think this is really key.
So some subset of the reproduction has to be correct enough to allow part of the mind, call it the Dubious Part, to be happy [this is not exactly what you said, which has deeper implications, but I currently want to focus on the drug-like system ideas for a bit]
So some subset of the reproduction has to be harmonically rich enough to allow part of the mind, call it the Sweet Tooth Part, to be happy
So some subset of the reproduction has to communicate complex patterns well enough to allow part of the mind, call it the Dream Catcher Part, to be happy and give us a mind-blowing experience
……………………
I’m just making this stuff up as we go along. There is intuitively some truths here, but I do not know if these are necessary and sufficient for us to be able to target minimal systems that are drug-like. For example, although it is nice to please the Sweet Tooth part of our mind – to get it out of the way and stop whining – it does not seem to be actually necessary for a drug-like experience.
Hmmmm……….
Take care,
-Mike