I’d like to start a discussion about which parts of a system a particular music genre taxes the most, not just these genres but others as well, but first an aside…
I think these 3 genres really have a lot in common. This seems kind of strange mostly because, I think, the people who like these various genres only like one and usually dislike (or hate with a passion, the others).
The commonalities:
* The foremost one is that they are all about voice, and not just voice but the story the voice is telling us about. Yeah, Opera has it’s orchestra and Folk its harmonic and guitar and Rap its bass rhythm, but seriously, it is all so forgettable [I would say Rap is less so, but that may be my prejudice].
* Not a lot of people like these genres, being kind of inaccessible in various ways, both in terms of content and with the difficulties in understanding a singing voice.
I think that Opera, however, because it was commissioned by the powers-that-be (or were), is delightfully risque sometimes but not, I would guess, controversial in its day.
However, because Folk and Rap are created by the disenfranchised among us, and can be characterized as ‘protests’ or just plain ‘angry’, they cause(d) some discomfort.
Neli does not like Rap. She thinks the songs, the musicians, are angry AT her. Me? I think they are speaking FOR me. Since about, what? 25%? of Rap is about male-female relations and the way society has gummed up the works [:-)] she is probably right.
But the other 75% is much more interesting, for me anyway, especially the ones about The Struggle of life. And this struggle is something that is also present in Folk and Opera…. [and the Blues. Maybe Blues is a firth primarily vocal genre as well…?].
Anyway, although I consider myself interested primarily in instrumentals, I have been listening to a lot of vocal music in the last year or so. Seems like we all probably ebb and flow through various genres as the years go by… 🙂
