SHOW REPORT
Commentary

Festival Son & Image
The Montreal High-end Audio Show

March 24th-26th, 2006

* Denotes a product carried by Audio Federation

 

 

The world according to Audiophiles... Montreal style.
 

 

 

The
Sound - Part Two


 


 

Here we continue describing our impressions of the Montreal Show, room by room. This is in no particular order - though it happens to closely resemble the order in which we first visited the rooms - and we do seem to like to visit what we guess are going to the most likely prospects for great sound first for some reason.

 

 

The Pathos CD player
 

Room by room, then, here are our impressions of the very best and the most expensive rooms.

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The Pathos logo on top of the Pathos integrated amplifier.
 
Vivid Audio
Pathos
Accuphase

 
Lo Med Hi

Vivid Audio's B1 speaker
 
 

This room was very interesting. The sound was very nice and unconstrained, apparently due to the near zero box colorations of the Vivid speakers.

It was a big sound, open, with nice timbre.

The only drawback was that you could definitely hear the limitations of the amplifier and, less so, the CD player. There was fuzz and smear around the notes, both tonally, timing-wise, dynamic-wise and and imaging-wise, and there was little of the subtle expressions of the music that a higher-end source and, specifically, that a more upscale amplifier and preamplifier, would contribute.

But, I liked the sound here, although Neli has her reservations.

At least, that is how it sounded to these hungry ears.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The McIntosh MC2KW amplifier
 
McIntosh
 
Lo Med Hi

McIntosh speaker
McIntosh speaker

This room was very terrible.

After a certain point, it becomes more efficient to describe a system's sound as it differs from noise, as opposed to how it differs from the absolute 'real thing'.

I blame the speakers.

The hearsay is that when asked how they decided how many tweeters to use ( counted over 100 per speaker) they said they put as many on as their big amplifier could handle.

Look, if they want to throw a bunch of drivers and a big box together and call it a speaker, that's fine. I bet a lot of people are impressed by the hugeness and by the overwhelming SPL-ness of it and that some people will buy it.

But if you are reading this - I hope you have better sense. I mean, unless you really do not want any females, dogs, audiophiles, Martians and I do not know what else within 100 yards of your system.

I really wonder whether B&O, and McIntosh are going for the upscale Bose crowd by building bigger heavier Bose-like speakers - keeping the same sound - just making it louder. Who knows, maybe they will make a bundle with this approach.

At least, that is how it sounded to these poor old ears.

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Jadis preamplifier
 
Jadis
Pierre Gabriel

 
Lo Med Hi

Pierre Gabriel speaker
 
 

This room was a little mystifying.

First, there is a ton of Jadis equipment in this system. Top-of-the-line wall-to-wall sweet sounding electronics.

Then you have these new speakers. $190K speakers. OK, I can see you are now sitting down and ready for this.

Well... There isn't much to get ready for. After all is said and heard, this turned out to be more of an Impressive system than anything else. There was a little emotion, and a little imaging, but....

And it only sounded sweet in a small frequency range, the upper midrange area. Otherwise it sounded neutral and a little confused. They cranked some kind of percussion track and the speakers do do bass. Yessiree.

I suppose it was kind of enjoyable, but I would rank a dozen systems of the show higher on the enjoyability scale.

But, impressive? Yes. As a purely impressive speaker it is right up there with the big JM Lab and Dali and Genesis etc.

Personally I prefer the Wilson Alexandria X2, as it is both Impressive and almost real. I like real. But for those who hate Wilson, and want a primarily impressive speaker well... you might want to check these out.

At least, that is how it sounded to these bored ears.

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Bluenote CD player

Tri-Cell Enterprises'
ELAC
Korato
Clearaudio
Bluenote
Room
 
Lo Med Hi

ELAC speaker
 
 

I'm writing about this room when it was using the ELAC speakers. It also used the Bluenote speakers - during the first few days.

I think I prefer these ELAC speakers.

This system was actually pretty fun to listen to. It had s sense of detailed dynamic about it - it was able to render the attack of the notes pretty darn well - something I think only the little Kharma system did as well. The note's follow through wasn't anything to write home about - but it wasn't bad either.

Tonality, balance, everything was as enjoyable as many of the better systems at this show.

I liked this system. Neli spent a lot more time in this room, so maybe she will have more to say.

At least, that is how it sounded to these satisfied ears.

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Bluenote CD player
 
Raysonic
 
Lo Med Hi

ELAC speaker
 
 

The Raysonic system was yet another enjoyable system.

A little on the sweet and warm side, it was nonetheless sufficiently detailed and with a continuousness that I found myself liking the sound in this room.

I didn't get a chance to check out the top to bottom frequency response of the soundstaging - so I can't say much about them things.

I think Neli also mentioned liking this system when she visited it at a later time.

At least, that is how it sounded to these soothed ears.

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Tenor 75 OTL amplifier
 
RL Acoustique
Tenor
Audio Aero*

 
Lo Med Hi

RL Acoustiqu Lamhorn 1.8 speaker with AER MD3B drivers
 
Audio Aero Prestige CD / SACD player

We were happy to see the Tenor OTL amplifiers at the show. We have heard these amps many times on the Kharma speakers and think that the two were an amazingly synergistic pair. We have also heard them on a number of other speakers as well.

Unfortunately, there wasn't as much synergy here with the RL Acoustique Lamhorn speakers.

The sound was kind of thin and dead sounding, with many of the notes not so much clipped off, as damped off near the end of each note -fading away much too quickly.

All in all, this room was a disappointment. No matter how hard I tried to like the sound (and we think the Audio Aero CD player with the Tenor is another match made in audio heaven - but you need the right speakers) it just wasn't all that enjoyable.

At least, that is how it sounded to these patient ears.

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Mimetism Preamplifier
 
Cabasse
Mimetism
CEC
BIS Audio

 
Lo Med Hi

Cabasse monitor speaker
 
 
 

This was a fun room.

It kind of surprised us. And not just seeing the electronics who we usually associate with their traditional usually belt-driven transports.

The sound was rich and lively, the bass was able to fill up the room nicely, and all in all we both enjoyed it quite a bit.

Never been sure about their bigger speakers, but we can certainly understand now why some people really like these little puppies, uh, monitors.

At least, that is how it sounded to these four ears.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Weiss's Jason transport
 
Focus Audio
Vitus Audio
Weiss

 
Lo Med Hi

Focus Audio speaker
 

This should of been a kickass room.

Not that it was awful or anything. But each of these components has earned some amount of respect. Some of them a tremendous amount of respect (the Weiss, at the very least).

But this was a blah system. Kind of flat and dull, plodding along. Well rounded, nice frequency balance, it had all that. But richness, PRaT, emotion, delicacy, quickness, etc. were not present during my listening.

Maybe the room was too small. Maybe the cables sucked, I don't know. But each time I hear the Vitus or Focus Audio, I expect the world and get a pea.

We really would like to find other solid state that would compete with the Edge that we carry - we like to offer our customers choices. But over and over again we get disappointed.

And the speakers look awesome, great build quality. But.... we are still wanting.

So, all in all, this room was a disappointment.

At least, that is how it sounded to these curious ears.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Main system equipment rack
 
Naim
 
Lo Med Hi

Naim speaker almost flat against the wall.
 
 

This system surprised us. It could play Frank Zappa.

Now, we do not play a lot of Frank Zappa. A little bit too much anger and angst at the lack of intelligence in the world - we got enough of that in our lives right now, thank you.

But it is great music. And it is hard for a system to get right. Heck, it is hard for a system not to totally fuck it up.

The Naim system did not fuck it up. It was lean, but well-balanced. It didn't collapse into a muddle or wall of sound.

Not sure how all much all of this cost - and throw enough money at the problem and a system will render Zappa sufficiently well, if you are lucky.

Anyway, kudos for playing Zappa and double kudos for it sounding decent.

Neli and I both thought this system had potential and we enjoyed it during our stay.

At least, that is how it sounded to these his and her ears.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Linn Unidisk 1.1 CD player and Linn Klimax Kontrol
 
Linn
 
Lo Med Hi

Linn's Artikulat speaker
 
 
 

Uh Oh.

Hey, I liked the old Linn Klimax amplifiers. Clean and fast. I loved the old Linn CD-12 player.

But this system...

The problem was with the midrange and down. It not only hugged the speaker, it was like it was trapped in the speaker. Very much like there was a lot of resonance in the speaker enclosure and very mid-fi sounding.

Dull, incorrect frequency and tone, incorrect note envelope, yadayadayada.

Well, Linn made great speakers at their price points in the past - I am sure they will do it again. But this system...

was a big disappointment.

At least, that is how it sounded to these sad ears.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Red Wine Audio preamp


Omega Speaker System
Red Wine Audio
Olive Symphony

 

Lo Med Hi

Omega Super 3 XRS speaker

Olive Symphony
 
Olive Symphony

These guys got something going for them.

With speakers using hemp, called the HempTones. With speakers in the $500 to $1500 price range. With an enthusiasm  that is contagious.

The sound was rich and tuneful and enjoyable.

No, it probably didn't do anything really well, and there was something out of phase or something because there wasn't a center image at all.

But this is what enjoying music and the pursuit of its reproduction is all about. Whether it is a quarter of a million dollar system or a pair of $1500 speakers - if you don't have the passion, where is the fun in it all?

Neli spent a lot more time in here than I. Perhaps she has some more comments on the sound.

But I give this room a thumbs up and hope to hear it again at the next show.

At least, that is how it sounded to these happy ears.

 
 
  The Carpentry
Experience

 

 
     
 


The Pierre Gabriel speaker

 

 

 


The Peak Consult Empress speaker

 

 

 


The Sonus Faber Stradivarius speaker

 

 

 


The Sonus Faber Guarnari Memento speaker

 

 


The Avalon Eidolon Vision speaker

 

 

 


Lithophon speaker
 

 

 


JAS speaker

 

 

 


Aurum Integris Active 300B speaker

 

 

 


Edgarhorn speaker

 

 

 


Primare speaker

 

 

 


Acoustic Zen Adagio speaker

 

 

 


HRS MXR Equipment Rack

 

 

 

Copyright © Audio Federation, Inc.. All rights reserved.
All pictures in this report are freely copyable and distributable.

Home Magazine Store

Guide

Blog Music